Thursday, November 19, 2026

NVDIA Sell-off

SharkWater Trading  •  Semis Desk • Earnings • NVDA

Kress Beat the Guide by $7.8 Billion and Set the Bar at $130 Billion. Nvidia Sold Off Anyway.

November 19, 2026 • After the close

Bottom Line Up Front

Nvidia (Nasdaq: NVDA) delivered its first report without Jensen Huang, and it was a clean beat on every line that matters. Q3 FY2027 revenue was $115.8 billion, up 103 percent year over year, against the company's own guide of $108.0 billion, and the Q4 guide is $130.0 billion, plus or minus 3 percent, with zero China data center compute assumed. Kress stood behind a full number, which is exactly what I said I wanted to see.

The tape did not care. The stock opened Wednesday up 2.4 percent, never got near the $164 line, and closed at $150.96, down 2.89 percent. Thursday made it worse: $145.98, down 3.30 percent, through the $148.80 low to a new 52-week low of $145.71 (Motley Fool, NOT VERIFIED). The market accepted the numbers and sold the governance. The business question is answered. The leadership question got louder.

What Nvidia reported

The release came out November 17 for the quarter ended October 25, 2026. Revenue landed $7.8 billion over the $108.0 billion midpoint and about $5.7 billion over the top of the range. Data Center was 93 percent of the company. Street consensus was about $109.1 billion, per LSEG as cited by CNBC in secondhand coverage.

ItemQ3 FY27Comparison
Revenue$115.8B+20% q/q, +103% y/y
Data Center$107.6B+21% q/q, +110% y/y
Edge Computing$8.2B+14% q/q, +42% y/y
Gross margin (GAAP / non-GAAP)74.8% / 74.9%Q2: 75.0% / 75.0%
Diluted EPS (GAAP / non-GAAP)$2.70 / $2.68Year-ago: $1.30 / $1.27
GAAP net income$65.3BIncludes $1.8B equity gains
Free cash flow$43.8BQ2: $21.3B
Capital returned$28.1B$22.1B buybacks; ~$227.3B authorization left
Inventory$39.7BJanuary: $21.4B

Source: NVIDIA Q3 FY2027 results release, November 17, 2026, read on nvidianews.nvidia.com. Non-GAAP no longer excludes stock-based compensation as of Q1 FY27, with prior periods restated.

Inventory nearly doubled since January. On a supply-constrained company that is fuel for Rubin, not a glut, but it is worth tracking.

The guide, with the extra week taken out

Q4 FY2027 is a 14-week quarter. The release says so, and Kress confirmed it on the call. That matters more than the headline.

MeasureQ3 (13 weeks)Q4 guide (14 weeks)
Revenue$115.8B$130.0B ±3%
Revenue per week~$8.9B~$9.3B
Non-GAAP gross margin74.9%71.0% to 72.0%
Non-GAAP opex$8.8B~$10.7B
China data center compute$2.4B licensed Hopper (per call)$0 assumed

Source: NVIDIA release, November 17, 2026. Per-week figures are SharkWater arithmetic, not company guidance. China figure per Fortune's account of the call.

On the calendar the guide is 12 percent growth. Per week it is about 4 percent. The low end of the range, $126.1 billion, is about 1 percent weekly growth. Q4 consensus was about $125.1 billion, per LSEG via CNBC, so the guide still clears the Street after the adjustment.

The margin line is the one the bears will use. Three points of gross margin is real money at this scale. It is also what a Rubin ramp looks like, since new platforms carry lower margins until yields and mix settle. The guide does not say which it is, and Kress did not volunteer a bridge. She did lift the fiscal 2028 growth outlook to about 75 percent, up from the roughly 70 percent Huang gave three months ago, per Fortune and The Motley Fool.

What the call said, and what it would not say

Chair Harvey Jones opened by closing the door: "We will not be addressing or taking questions on today's call regarding the circumstances of Jensen's resignation and the ongoing investigation." He said the board "does not intend to reinstate Jensen as CEO," hours after Huang wrote on X that he "would be honored" to return. Jones said Huang "voluntarily resigned" after "disclosure of personal behavior inconsistent with the company's code of conduct." A search firm is retained, internal and external candidates are in play, and there is no timeline. Quotes as reported by Fortune.

The board also stood up a National Security and Export Control Oversight Committee, chaired by director Suzanne Nora Johnson, with directors Stephen Neal and John Dabiri, per Reuters. The National Security and Global Trade Compliance teams now report to it. Reuters notes Nvidia had no chief compliance officer per its 2026 proxy.

  • China: $2.4 billion of licensed Hopper data center sales in the quarter. "We are no longer shipping licensed Hopper data center products to China." On the new Commerce rules, Nvidia is "still going to spend some time studying those."
  • Demand: "demand far exceeding supply."
  • Concentration: frontier AI labs at about 15 percent of data center revenue this year.
  • Disclosure: the 10-Q comes "in the coming weeks," with the regional revenue breakdown.
  • Rubin: in the release, "Vera Rubin is off to an explosive start, our roadmap is on track."

Kress call quotes per Fortune, November 17, 2026. Rubin quote from the NVIDIA release.

Then what nobody asked. Eight analysts, one question each. Per Fortune, none asked about the Wall Street Journal's report that the SEC is opening a civil probe into whether Nvidia's disclosures misled investors. None asked about Singapore, which was 22 percent of revenue by billing location in the July 2025 10-Q, or about Megaspeed, the Singapore data center company now under a criminal probe that the Commerce and Justice departments confirmed on Monday. Nvidia put Megaspeed on a no-sell list in June 2025, per those departments. Bank of America's Vivek Arya came closest, with a question on talent retention.

The captain is gone and the board will not take him back. The divers are still down, and the Street chose not to ask what they have found.

The tape

TimeNVDASource
Nov 12, premarket (last post)$154.68Business Upturn, NOT VERIFIED
Nov 17 close, before the print$155.46, -0.44%S&P Global via StockAnalysis; matches Techi, Heygotrade
Nov 18, 5:06 AM ET premarket peak$161.66, +4.0%Techi, NOT VERIFIED
Nov 18 open$159.19, +2.4%S&P Global via StockAnalysis; matches Heygotrade
Nov 18 high / low$159.70 / $150.40S&P Global via StockAnalysis, Techi, Heygotrade
Nov 18 close$150.96, -2.89%S&P Global via StockAnalysis, Motley Fool, Tech Times
Nov 19 high / low$158.13 / $145.71Motley Fool, NOT VERIFIED
Nov 19 close$145.98, -3.30%Motley Fool, NOT VERIFIED

Nov 17 and 18: S&P Global Market Intelligence data via StockAnalysis, cross-checked against press. Nov 19: The Motley Fool, 4:00 PM ET, single source.

Wednesday volume was about 346 million shares, more than double the three-month average of 156.7 million cited by The Motley Fool. Thursday's close sits about 40 percent below the 52-week high of $243.37, and Thursday's low of $145.71 is the new 52-week low.

Wednesday, the money rotated again. AMD rose 5.3 percent to $530.14 and Broadcom 3.6 percent to about $354, while CoreWeave fell 4.1 percent, per The Motley Fool and Techi. Same pattern as November 12: sell Nvidia, buy the competitors, keep the AI trade.

Thursday broke the pattern. The Nasdaq fell 2.25 percent and the S&P 500 2.02 percent. AMD dropped 7.7 percent to $489.19 after Hunterbrook Media disclosed a short position tied to China shipments, and Broadcom fell 2.1 percent, per The Motley Fool and Yahoo Finance. The Motley Fool also points to Monday's new rule blocking Chinese firms from remote access to advanced chips through overseas data centers, and to an early lift from Anthropic's IPO that faded. Thursday was a market day, not only an Nvidia day.

Techi counts Nvidia closing below its next-day open after nine of its last ten reports. This was one more. Open to close was down about 5 percent.

The Street, as reported in press, not ours: Barclays' Tom O'Malley wrote that the "concern on near-term is largely addressed." KeyBanc's John Vinh wrote that successor uncertainty "likely keeps the stock range-bound." Moody's moved its Nvidia credit outlook from positive to stable on governance, per Heygotrade. Morgan Stanley trimmed its target to $260 earlier this week and kept Overweight, per The Motley Fool.

The Bull Case

  • The guide held without the founder. $130 billion, full range, zero China. The fear going in was a narrowed or withheld guide. It did not happen.
  • Cheap on the numbers. At Thursday's $145.98, NVDA trades at about 9.4 times the fiscal 2028 consensus EPS of $15.55 that Techi cites. That is a utility multiple on a company guiding 75 percent growth.
  • The cash is real. $43.8 billion of free cash flow in one quarter and $227 billion of buyback room. The company can absorb its own stock at these prices for a long time.
  • China is out of the numbers. Any China revenue from here is upside, not risk.

The Bear Case

  • The probes are multiplying, not closing. A board investigation, a reported SEC civil probe, a confirmed criminal probe of a Singapore customer Nvidia had already blacklisted, and House interviews. None of that is a demand problem. All of it is a disclosure problem.
  • The margin guide steps down three points. On a 14-week quarter, per-week growth is about 4 percent. Strip out the calendar and the deceleration is sharper than the headline.
  • The call ducked the hard questions. Refusing Huang questions is defensible. Refusing to even frame the investigation, while analysts skip Singapore, leaves holders guessing.
  • The chart has not repaired. The $164 level never got tested, and Thursday closed below the $148.80 low at a new 52-week low.

The SharkWater Take

Last week I said that if I own Nvidia, I want to own it after Kress has stood behind a Q4 number, even at a higher price. She stood behind the number. The price came in lower, not higher. So the condition I set is met, and on the business, the scenario I called "the discount was about Huang, not the business" is the one that printed.

The tape disagreed for a reason. The risk did not leave with Huang. It moved from the CEO's office to the compliance file. The market is not pricing slower AI. It is pricing a disclosure problem it cannot size yet, and Wednesday's rotation into AMD and Broadcom said the same thing, before Thursday's broader selloff took the whole group down.

My plan has to respect my own line. Below, I said a close under $148.80 means the market is still adding risk, not pricing it. Thursday closed at $145.98. So no starter position yet. I want a close back above $148.80, or the 10-Q regional breakdown, before I put a dollar in. Full size still waits for a named permanent CEO or a scope on the SEC question. The numbers earned a look. The tape has not earned an entry.

Execution Notes

Scenarios for the next catalysts, not predictions. None of these are price targets.

If we seeWhat it means
10-Q shows Singapore share falling and no new disclosure on the probesThe compliance discount starts to unwind. The $164 area is the first test from below.
SEC probe confirmed with a scope limited to disclosure wordingHeadline pain, manageable substance. The business case holds.
Any finding that controlled chips reached restricted end users through Nvidia's channelNew problem, new post. Today's prices stop being a useful reference.
A permanent CEO named from outsideExpect a reset in Q1 guide style and capex posture. Wait for the first call.
  • Levels: The $148.80 line broke Thursday. The new floor is Thursday's $145.71 low. A close back above $148.80 is the first sign the market has stopped adding risk.
  • Margin bridge: Watch the Q4 gross margin bridge in the 10-Q. If Nvidia attributes the step-down to Rubin ramp costs, the bear case loses its best number.
  • Peers: Watch AMD and AVGO. Two report days in a row, the money left Nvidia and stayed in the sector, then Thursday took the whole group down. If Nvidia starts holding up better than its peers, the leadership discount is fading.
  • Options: No chain was pulled. No premiums or implied moves are shown, live or theoretical. Any premium-selling idea needs a live chain.

Data Gaps

  • Unverified prices: Thursday's $145.98 close, its $158.13 to $145.71 range, and the Nov 18 premarket peak each come from a single press source. The Nov 12 premarket quote is an aggregator screen.
  • Secondhand consensus: The $109.1 billion Q3 and $125.1 billion Q4 consensus figures are LSEG as cited by CNBC in other outlets. The CNBC pages did not load.
  • Call transcript: Call quotes come from Fortune's account. We did not read a full transcript.
  • Valuation: The 9.4 times forward multiple is SharkWater arithmetic on a consensus EPS figure Techi cites, not read from a data provider.
  • The SEC probe: A Wall Street Journal report. We saw no Nvidia comment and no 8-K.
  • The CEO search: A Bloomberg report, cited by Techi, says the search firm has contacted Arm CEO Rene Haas. That is a report of an approach, not a candidacy.
  • Congress: Fortune reports Huang and general counsel Tim Teter agreed to transcribed interviews with three House committees. Other outlets report different timing.
  • Not yet filed: The 10-Q and its regional breakdown, including the first look at Singapore since the scandal broke.

Tight lines. SharkWater

Educational and informational purposes only. Not personalized investment advice. Financial figures from "NVIDIA Announces Financial Results for Third Quarter Fiscal 2027" (nvidianews.nvidia.com, November 17, 2026). Call quotes as reported by Fortune (November 17, 2026); committee details per Reuters via Yahoo Finance; fiscal 2028 outlook per Fortune and The Motley Fool. Analyst comments as quoted by Yahoo Finance. Consensus figures are LSEG as cited by CNBC in secondhand coverage, NOT VERIFIED. November 17 and 18 NVDA prices are S&P Global Market Intelligence data via StockAnalysis, matching press reports. November 19 prices and peer moves from The Motley Fool, Yahoo Finance, Techi and Heygotrade, NOT VERIFIED where not cross-checked. The SEC probe is a press report. Allegations against Huang are unproven. Options involve substantial risk of loss. The author may hold positions in securities discussed. Do your own work.

No comments:

Post a Comment